Cayman Islands vs. Turks and Caicos: My Honest Travel Comparison
One of the most common searches online is “Cayman Islands vs. Turks and Caicos.” It is also a hot topic among travelers looking for an exotic tropical getaway. Since I have been to both recently, I figured I would share my direct insight. The perspective you are getting here is fresh, not recycled information from years ago.
For years I was intrigued by both destinations. Both are known for award-winning beaches, tropical weather, and that postcard-perfect idea of paradise. Here is my side-by-side comparison.
Travel Distance
Flying from the West Coast (San Francisco International Airport), both trips took about 7.5 to 8 hours of airtime.
-
Grand Cayman: Stopover in Charlotte, NC, then a 2-hour flight to Grand Cayman.
-
Turks & Caicos: Stopover in Miami (5.5 hours), then a 1.5-hour flight to Providenciales.
-
Return trips: Both routed back through Miami.
Travel time was pretty even, so I would call this category a tie. For East Coast travelers your travel time will be a lot shorter since you won’t be making the trek across the country.
Stay & Resorts
We stayed on the world-famous beaches in both destinations: Seven Mile Beach in Grand Cayman and Grace Bay in Turks & Caicos.
-
Turks & Caicos: This one gets the win for accommodations. My family had the entire resort to ourselves. When I say we had the whole resort I mean literally. No other guests, just us and the staff for the whole week. Our suite was massive with two bedrooms, a full kitchen, living and dining rooms, plus a huge lanai (patio). The grounds were gorgeous, and I even paid the ground gardeners to grab us fresh coconuts straight from the trees. Grace Bay was just a short walk from our door, and it was every bit as beautiful as the photos. Keep on reading to learn how my family was able to have a resort to ourselves for the week!
-
Grand Cayman: The resort was not quite as grand as the one in Turks & Caicos, but the food and staff made up for it. My daughter and I are coconut fanatics, and when I brought coconuts back from outside, the staff immediately grabbed them, and went around the property looking for a machete to open them for us with smiles. The included breakfast was amazing, and the service felt next-level.
Verdict: Turks wins for the resort itself, but Grand Cayman wins for hospitality and food.
Beaches
This was tough because both are world-class.
-
Seven Mile Beach (Grand Cayman): Soft white sand, crystal clear / turquoise water, iconic and lively, with perfect swimming conditions. Something about it feels on another level.
-
Grace Bay (Turks & Caicos): Stunning, soft sand, turquoise water, pure paradise.
But the real gem was Sapodilla Bay Beach in Turks & Caicos. Out of all the beaches I have been to (Grand Cayman, Jamaica, Cozumel, Hawaiian Islands, Guam, Puerto Vallarta, Miami, Florida Keys), Sapodilla Bay tops them all.
Tucked away off a small road, you park on the shoulder, walk a short path, and then you are in paradise. A shallow, crystal-clear saltwater pool with soft white sand and no rocks or reef. It felt surreal. While on Turks & Caicos we took a boat to Half Moon Bay beach and Iguana Island and the sand and water was something I’ve never experienced.
Verdict: Turks & Caicos wins overall for beaches.
Activities & Attractions
-
Grand Cayman: Stingray City and Starfish Point were highlights. Swimming with stingrays was unforgettable. We also visited Rum Point and the Turtle Farm, both must-dos.
-
Turks & Caicos: We did a boat trip to Half Moon Bay on Iguana Island, explored Chalk Sound, and checked off a bucket-list experience by swimming with sharks in the open ocean. I dove in, snorkeled alongside reef sharks, and even followed one underwater. For me, as an ocean lover, this was a dream come true.
Verdict: Both offer unforgettable activities. No clear winner.
Land & Scenery
Both islands are flat, unlike Jamaica or Hawai‘i with their mountains.
-
Turks & Caicos: Dry, arid landscape.
-
Grand Cayman: Greener and more lush.
Verdict: Grand Cayman wins for scenery.
Locals & Culture
Both destinations are full of friendly people.
-
Grand Cayman: Felt even warmer overall. I was surprised to discover a large Filipino community there, alongside other Caribbean cultures. Shout out to my boy Diego Pino at the Turtle Center in Cayman
-
Turks & Caicos: The people in Turks & Caicos were nice but at times I felt like we were being an inconvenience or bothering people when asking questions or shopping. The greatest locals we met and hung out with were the founders of Nikki’s Trinkets (Nikki & O’Brien). They were the greatest and friends we’ll have for life.
Verdict: Slight edge to Grand Cayman.
Food
-
Turks & Caicos: Chinson’s had amazing jerk chicken. https://www.visittci.com/providenciales/chinsons
-
Grand Cayman: More variety and higher quality overall. Chicken Chicken was excellent, and I even found one of the best sizzling Sisig dishes ever at Popo Jebs.
Verdict: Grand Cayman wins for food.
Driving & Getting Around
Driving was a challenge at first on the left side with mostly roundabouts, but manageable.
-
Turks & Caicos: Roads were rougher.
-
Grand Cayman: Roads were smoother, and the overall driving experience was easier.
Verdict: Grand Cayman.
Comfort & Infrastructure
Grand Cayman felt more developed, polished, and secure overall, with modern hospitals and strong infrastructure. Turks & Caicos, while beautiful, feels like it is still catching up, almost like Grand Cayman years ago.
Verdict: Grand Cayman.
Cost
Both are expensive, with few all-inclusive options compared to Jamaica or other Caribbean destinations. Think U.S. prices for food, resorts, and groceries. You are paying premium either way.
Verdict: Tie.
Time of the Year:
We visited both Islands almost a year apart, and both trips in October. Turks & Caicos has an “off-season” or “slow time” during the months of June through October and it can be felt with a lot of shops and restaurants being closed. Grand Cayman didn’t have this. Everything was open when we visited Grand Cayman. The pros to traveling to Turks & Caicos during their off-season is that visitors are spread out amongst the various resorts in Grace Bay. Because of this, we got lucky with our timing and were fortunate to have our resort to ourselves. When we arrived, we were surprised that there wasn’t a single person in any of the pools, at the pool bar, or anywhere on the resorts grounds. We assumed they were at the beach or touring our the Island. After some time we asked the front desk where everyone is at, and that’s when they informed us that we were the only guests in the resort. It was weird at first because it was really quiet, but by the next day it was amazing!
So if you want to experience the possibility of having a resort to yourself without paying a lot, if you travel to Turks & Caicos in October you might get lucky!
Final Results
If someone handed me a free trip and said, “Pick one,” I would choose Grand Cayman.
Turks & Caicos has the edge on beaches and gave me some once-in-a-lifetime experiences, but overall, Grand Cayman feels more comfortable, developed, and welcoming. Both destinations are worth visiting, and I will be returning to each with my family soon.
Remember, that Turks & Caicos has an “off-season” that runs from June through October, so a lot of shops will be closed and it’s the “slow time” in the Islands. There was still a lot of visitors when we were in Grand Turk and if that’s their “slow time” then I could only imagine what their non off-season is like because there was a lot of visitors. If you want tranquility and peace and quiet go during the “off-season” and if you’re lucky, you might have a whole resort to yourself!
If you are planning a trip and want recommendations and connections for the resorts, rental cars, boats, or tour services, feel free to reach out. Happy travels!
